Innovating Leadership:
Co-Creating Our Future

Hosted by Maureen Metcalf

Conversations with global thought leaders on leadership, culture, and innovation—designed for executives navigating complexity and building resilient organizations.

The Good Fight: Using Productive Conflict
Episode Description

Liane Davey argues that avoiding conflict is more costly than engaging it, coining the term “conflict debt” for the unresolved issues that accumulate every time we sidestep a needed discussion. That debt shows up as poor prioritization, diluted resources, and disengaged teams. She offers three techniques for making conflict constructive, validating others before advancing your own view, reframing opponents as allies around shared purpose, and using open-ended questions rather than accusations, all captured in her memorable rule that if you can’t say anything nice, make sure you say it nicely.

Key Takeaways
  • Conflict debt accumulates every time a needed discussion or disagreement is avoided.
  • Unaddressed conflict leads to poor prioritization, diluted resources, and team disengagement.
  • Validating others’ concerns before presenting your own sets a constructive tone.
  • Reframing conflict as collaborative problem-solving turns adversaries into allies.
  • Open-ended questions, rather than accusatory statements, preserve dignity and create paths forward.
Why This Episode Matters

Executives come away understanding that avoiding conflict carries a real cost, and gain practical techniques for turning disagreement into productive, respectful problem-solving.

Featuring

Liane Davey, Co-founder of 3COze Inc.

Episode Topics

Podcast Air Date

May 11, 2021

Episode Duration

44min

Watch the episode

Season 7
Episode Number 19

Episode Content:

Conflict Strategies for Nice People

Liane Davey, as part of the World Business and Executive Coach Summit (WBECS) series, shares this blog with us as their companion podcast

We’re not having enough conflict. When we avoid issues that we need to address, we get into what I call “conflict debt.” What is conflict debt? Essentially, each time you avoid a discussion, debate, or disagreement that you should be having, you add that issue to the list of unresolved issues. If you should be introducing novel ideas to get your organization out of a rut but you think, “that’s gonna’ ruffle some feathers,” so you stay quiet, you’re incurring debt. If you should be telling a coworker that he’s not pulling his weight, but you just can’t be bothered starting a fight, that’s conflict debt.

Like with any debt, conflict debt accrues interest that costs us dearly. As organizations, we fail to prioritize, dilute resources, and accomplish little. As teams, we work around problem people and overwhelm the capable ones. As individuals, we stifle our concerns and become increasingly disgruntled, stressed, and disengaged.

Conflict debt is too costly. We need to surface and work through conflict, but the voices inside our heads give us so many reasons why we should avoid it. Perhaps the loudest voice is the one that tells us conflict isn’t nice. But is that true?

You might think conflict has to be loud, or aggressive, or rigid. It doesn’t. You can have conflict nicely by choosing words skillfully and keeping your tone level and your body language open. There are a few techniques you can use to have conflict nicely.

Validating versus invalidating

For the most part, grown adults in the workplace understand that they can’t always get what they want. What really frustrates people is when they don’t feel that they’ve been heard. Unfortunately, the moment you get into a conflict, your attention gets laser focused on pleading your case, rather than hearing theirs. When they say, “We need to drive more traffic into the stores, I’m dropping prices,” you immediately go to, “We need to protect our margins!”

The most powerful thing you can do to have conflict nicely is to leave your colleague with the impression that you understand their point. That means you need to start by really listening to and carefully reflecting their concerns before even mentioning your own. “You’re focused on driving traffic into the stores. Tell me what our numbers look like this week.” If the first thing out of your mouth is their perspective rather than your own, you’ve set a positive tone for the whole discussion.

Ally versus adversary

Conflict is particularly unpleasant when you make the other person feel like you are working in opposite directions. Antagonistic conflict pits the two of you against each other and leaves the other person feeling isolated. Imagine standing facing one another pulling in a tug-of-war. “We NEED to drop our prices, we’re not going to get anyone in our store at these prices!” “Yeah, well we NEED to make a profit and we’re going to lose our shirts at that discount!”

Having conflict nicely requires that you pivot so that you are facing the same direction and looking at the problem together, as allies. The secret is to appeal to a higher purpose that you have in common. For example, “Look, I know you think we need to drop our prices and I’m pushing hard to keep them level. We both want to make it through the holiday season profitably. How can we think about this differently?” As soon as you can start saying “we” and stop saying “you,” the conflict will feel much nicer.

Productive versus unproductive

A sure way to be the bad guy in a conflict is to back someone into a corner. Making assertive statements, pointing a finger, and shutting the conversation down with closed questions will leave your colleague with no way out. You know exactly how people behave when they are trapped, they either fight more aggressively or they back down. Neither is going to leave them with the impression that you’re a nice person. “Do you want to be the person who destroyed our Q4 margin?”

The alternative is to create a path forward with everything you say. Rather than trapping the person so that their only option is to contradict you or disagree with you, ask open-ended questions that allow them to explain their position. “How are you thinking about the impact on our margin if we discount prices that far?” Even when you’re proposing a solution to the problem, pose it as a question to test whether it works, “Ok, what if we were to take the sale to 30% and sweeten it with a free gift with $50 or more?”

If someone raised you to believe, “if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all,” you might be avoiding conflict altogether. That’s not good for anybody. Instead, focus your efforts on having conflict nicely. Make your colleague feel heard and understood, make them feel like an ally, rather than an adversary, and constantly leave room for both of you to work together toward a solution. From now on, “if you can’t say anything nice, make sure you say it nicely.”

Resources:

Business today is more competitive than ever; staying ahead requires you to make tough calls, face hard choices, and work through conflict. But productive conflict is so rare. Why? Because productive conflict requires a different mindset, new skills, and repeatable processes—none of which come naturally. Liane Davey joins Maureen to discuss building a productive conflict culture.

Other episodes you’ll enjoy

Guest(s):

Liane Davey, Co-founder of 3COze Inc.

Guest(s) Bio:

Liane Davey is a New York Times Bestselling author of three books, including The Good Fight: Use Productive Conflict to Get Your Team and Your Organization Back on Track. Known as the Water Cooler Psychologist, she is a regular contributor to the Harvard Business Review and is frequently called on by media outlets for her experience on leadership, team effectiveness, and productivity. As the co-founder of 3COze Inc., she advises on strategy and executive team effectiveness at companies such as Amazon, Walmart, TD Bank, Google, 3M, and SONY. Liane has a Ph.D. in Organizational Psychology.

Want to be a guest on the Innovating Leadership Podcast?

Want to sponsor the Innovating Leadership Podcast?

Our Podcast Team:

Maureen Metcalf

Maureen Metcalf

Host & Executive Producer

Dan Mushalko

Dan Mushalko

Editor & Producer

Jenna Reik

Guest Booking Manager

Love the show?

Leave us a review and rating:

   

    Transcript
    (auto-generated)

    Maureen: [00:00:09] Hi, welcome to Innovating Leadership: Co-Creating Our Future. Today, we’re going to be talking about the good fight using productive conflict. I’m your host, Maureen Metcalf. I’m the founder and CEO of the Innovative Leadership Institute, we help elevate the quality of leadership globally and work with leaders to co-create a thriving future. Our work includes helping leaders in navigating the disruptive trends that we’re all facing and developing strategies to transform themselves and their organizations to thrive now and in the future, I’m a regular contributor to Forbes and the lead author on an award-winning book series focusing on innovating how you lead and transforming your organization. I’m also a fellow with the International Leadership Association. I am delighted that our guest today is Leanne Davy. Leanne is a New York Times best-selling author of three books, including *The Good Fight* using productive conflict to get your team and your organization back on track. She is known as the water cooler psychologist. She’s a regular contributor to the Harvard Business Review and frequently called on by media outlets for her expertise in leadership, team effectiveness, and productivity. As a co-founder of the Three Cos, she advises on strategy and executive team effectiveness at companies such as Amazon, Walmart, TD Bank, Google, 3M, and Sony. Leanne also has her PhD in organizational psychology. So we all know that business today is more competitive than ever, and staying ahead requires you to make tough calls, face hard choices, and to work through conflict. But productive conflict is rare. Why is that? Because productive conflict requires a different mindset, new skills, and repeatable processes, none of which come naturally, and none of which most of us were taught as we were coming along in our careers. So today, Lainey and I are going to talk about building a productive conflict culture. So, Lainey, thank you so much for joining us.

    Liane: [00:02:17] Hi, Maureen. Oh, I just you made that the the mistake that my mother doomed me to my whole life. It’s Leanne. Just sorry. No, no, no. It’s because of the crazy spelling, but totally okay. Nice to be here.

    Maureen: [00:02:30] Thank you. So, Leanne, what do you want our listeners to know about you?

    Liane: [00:02:35] Oh, that’s a great question. Well, that name, the water cooler psychologist, is one that other people gave to me because they initially would hear that I had a PhD in psychology, and everyone would get a little worried. They’d make jokes about, “Do I need to lie on the couch? Are you going to ask about my mother? And so, probably the most important thing you need to know about me is I’m not that kind of psychologist, but really I’m somebody who’s fascinated by how humans are at work and all of the good, the bad, and the ugly that that entails. So that’s me in a nutshell.

    Maureen: [00:03:10] So why did you write this book?

    Liane: [00:03:13] Because I needed to read it. I and of course I think there are so many of us who write the books that we need. And what I mean when I say that is, you know, I grew up in a house that was very conflict averse. My family, particularly my father, did not like conflict and was very afraid of words being used and doing damage and leaving scar tissue. I think he people had said things to him in his life. He’s a very sensitive guy that you know stung him decades later, and so he was so careful with it that I grew up just in a house with zero conflict. In all my years, I never heard my parents raise their voices; just wasn’t done. And so the problem was when I ended up in the workplace with zero conflict skills, I learned very quickly about all the things that don’t go well, and learned that it’s very hard to advocate for yourself. It’s very hard to address just the normal frictions that come up when humans have to work together under a lot of pressure. It’s impossible to take scarce resources and make tough trade-offs if you don’t know how to have conflict and how to have it productively, so I didn’t see things in the marketplace. Certainly, there are great books about having an actual difficult conversation, including difficult conversations and fierce conversations and radical candor. And there was so little that helped get at the mindset of why do I feel this way? Why why am I so conflict averse? And also very little that helped us go beyond conflict as an event, like the conversation, and get it to become a habit. So, I needed to read this book, and given that nobody else had written it, I figured that well, I better just do it.

    Maureen: [00:04:59] You know, it’s. Interesting that you share about your background. Mine was my dad was a military officer, so much more direct. My mom was an artist and very conflict avoidant. So I was taught that the only way, especially for girls to stay stay safe, was avoid conflict and avoid men who were conflicting, which was not very effective as an adult professional, especially because as a consultant I was paid to have a point of view and afraid to share it because it felt literally felt unsafe. I was taught it’s not safe to argue with men and men who are taller or bigger, and at five two, everyone’s bigger. Part of the reason I’m sharing this is probably a lot of our listeners have come from various environments where we were literally discouraged from communicating and taught that it conflict was literally unsafe. So smart women did not disagree with men, and there were a lot of men and women who should be disagreed with, especially if that’s your job. So tell our listeners, please, a little bit more about to your point. We probably many of us have the books on our shelves? Crucial conversations, difficult conversations. What is different? You’ve certainly spelled out the need for the book.

    Liane: [00:06:28] Yeah.

    Maureen: [00:06:29] So walk us through kind of what’s the table of contents and some of what what makes this so valuable.

    Liane: [00:06:35] Let’s think about the book in three chunks. It’s written in three chunks, and let’s say that the middle of the book is the least unique contribution because the middle of the book, which I call the conflict code, which is how do I have conflict productively, is the most similar to all those other things that already exist. It just felt weird to write a book about productive conflict without addressing the conflict itself. So it’s there, but let’s go in two directions from that conflict conversation. The first section of the book gets to this issue of our unhealthy relationship with conflict, and it starts by helping people interrogate their own voices in their head and how those voices in their head affect how they think about conflict and what the pictures in their head. So, so for you, the word “unsafe” is a very potent word when you think of conflict, or at least when you did. So, I go back and look at all the voices. So, the four for me were my grandmother who told me if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all, and that’s when I learned conflict isn’t nice. The adults in my life who any time as a kid another kid started to cry would like descend on the scene, give you the now look what you’ve done, and you would get in trouble for someone else’s emotions. So that was the point at which we learned. Well, emotions are scary and bad, and we shouldn’t evoke them. The third one was my grade four teacher who taught me to mind my own business and taught me that if there’s conflict between two other people, I should turn away and not get involved and not help. And if you think about the Me Too movement and various other predatory behavior. How much of that was facilitated and enabled by people minding their own business, and then the fourth one was about the sort of be good and stay out of trouble idea and the the don’t speak truth to power and it’s better to just tough it out rather than try and make it better. So I start with I share mine. I’m very open about how I call them my itty bitty committee. All the the voices in my head that talk to me and tell me to avoid conflict, and I encourage the reader to do the same to figure out what are and and for you, you’ve just done a great job of that. Saying, look, this is the dynamic I grew up with. Here’s why I learned that conflict was unsafe, and here’s why I didn’t engage in it. So I start there, and then I go into I coined a phrase which has really caught on, which is that because of this we get into conflict debt, which is all of these issues that are coming at us that we really need to work through. But because we’re afraid, or we’re minding our own business, or because it wouldn’t be nice, we we let them pile up as debt on a credit card, and we pay interest, we pay penalties, and that conflict and resentment and issues tend to grow and build until the point where if they do come out, it’s then it erupts in something very unpleasant and very unhealthy. So I talk a lot about conflict debt. I help people to assess where there’s conflict debt in their lives and assess it both in terms of how is it affecting your organization in loss of growth, productivity, innovation, risk management. How’s it affecting your team in eroding trust and engagement? And. How’s it affecting you in mounting stress? So the whole beginning of the book is really a bunch of reframes to to to think differently. So all these voices in your head, how do you get rid of them? I always say the little voices on my shoulder. I have to like flick them off my shoulder, get rid of them, and replace them with a much healthier relationship where I understand that conflict is a natural part of healthy relationships and an important protection from unhealthy relationships, and and I need to reframe it. So the whole first part of the book helps you to confront that and and come to terms with that. Then we get into the section on okay, how do I actually do it? But the third section, which I’m most proud of is when I I got to the point where I said I go through organ and you probably do too Maureen I meet organizations and leaders all the time every day who have been through difficult conversations fierce conversations and they’re not behaving any differently because it’s just too big an ask it’s too aversive. It’s too unpleasant, right? Yeah.

    Maureen: [00:11:04] Go back to my situation. It’s unsafe to confront men. As long as I believe that it doesn’t matter how many classes I go through, I started with Peter Senge’s conversational recipes and learned to say, “Would you be open to an alternate point of view. If the answer was no, no more conversation. There was no crucial. There was no difficult. It was a simple question.

    Liane: [00:11:29] Yeah.

    Maureen: [00:11:29] Would you be open to an alternate point of view? And until I learned to navigate what was happening inside of me, it wasn’t a skill. It was a mindset and an incredibly deep-seated fear, fear, fear. Yeah, great. Yeah, bad stuff happens when girls, because this happened when I was a girl, disagree with men. Children to be seen and not heard. Yeah, you don’t argue with authority figures. Wait till your father gets home, and there would be a paddle or a belt or something. And my parents were good parents, so this isn’t Fashion Parent Day. That generation of parenting was about command and control, and the result of that was probably a generation of us, not just women, who were taught many of us that conflict can look physically dangerous, or because I’m not sure my dad was looking forward to coming home and picking up a big right kid. Yeah, so yeah, I don’t think anyone looked forward to those events.

    Liane: [00:12:40] Yeah,

    Maureen: [00:12:41] and so I love the idea that you’re helping people uncover the voices that got us here. My sense is, and it sounds like your research has clearly shown this, it’s not necessarily just a skill deficit that might be part of it,

    Liane: [00:12:58] right?

    Maureen: [00:12:59] But that it is a will or motivation or fear that really keeps us from putting in place the skills we can have.

    Liane: [00:13:08] Yeah. So the whole first section of the book has to goes. That’s where it goes deep. But the third section says, okay, now how do we make conflict less of a root canal and more like flossing, so it’s processes to never have to ask, “May I have a you know, may I disagree with you? May I have a fierce conversation? It’s processes you can do with your team that set up conflict as an obligation, rather than as a negative or a detracting from your role as a team player. And we actually help each member of a team understand their obligation to disagree, to bring diverse perspectives, to represent their stakeholders who might be different than the stakeholders of their teammates. So when we get through the third section and we learn how to treat conflict more like flossing, less like a root canal, then we’re so that’s the section I’m most proud of.

    Maureen: [00:14:03] You know, I love our leadership competency model looks at innately collaborative as one of the key skills, and that pulls from the idea that we need differing points of view. And if we’ve got people who can’t express a different point of view for any number of reasons, then we don’t. It doesn’t matter how much we put people in the same room or on Zooms. We don’t get it, Leanne. Thank you so much. And to our listeners, we are talking about the importance of difficult conversations and how they create a positive impact and a necessary impact on our business success, and for us as leaders, they’re required. Think about the question Leanne asked early on: What were the messages you got as a young person that framed how you think about conflict, either negative or positive? For some folks, conflict is. The only way to interact, Leanne. You talked about the third segment of your book being the process that turns conflict into habit. For many of our listeners, they don’t have one of those processes, which is why you wrote this book. This is intuitively correct. Tell us more about what you wrote about

    Liane: [00:15:20] yeah, so I’ll tell you a fun story because it makes it a little bit more fun to think about these ideas. So one of the things that I curse about all the time is that most of our language and imagery of teamwork is a boat full of rowers, and we see that image everywhere, and we hear the language of being in the same boat and pulling in the same direction, and in my experience, I find that imagery tends to reduce conflict-the good kind of conflict. Because you know, when people have an idea that’s different, or the plan is almost finished, and you think, “Oh, I think I spot a problem in it, you have this image in your head of, “Oh, I’m supposed to be pulling in the same direction, and so you tend to hold back on the issue. So I needed to have a different story, a different metaphor, a different picture, and my family provided the perfect one. And it’s a silly, silly story, but it turns out all these years later, it’s helped so many teams to create a conflict habit, and what it was is we we took our kids camping when they were little, and it was all good until a couple days in there was a big rainstorm coming, and we knew that our little tent was not going to keep us dry, so we drove to town to buy a big plastic tarpaulin, like the biggest tarp we could find, to cover the whole tent and provide us with some protection. And when we got to the store, they were mostly sold out except for this one sad little tiny tarp. So we brought it back to the campsite, and we tied ropes on each corner. And then the four of us had to sort of stretch it as tight as we could so that the rain would roll off of it and get it kind of centered and in the right spot so that with the way the wind was blowing, it was going okay until my husband decided that this was his moment to prove how strong he was. And with my five-year-old on the diagonal corner, he gave it a good yank and sent her flying into the mud puddle. And when I got her cleaned up, the nine-year-old at the time sort of rolled her eyes, and while we were pulling, she let go, and the corner of the tarp came flying up, and the tent was getting soaked, and it was just a disaster. And a long time later, I realized that oh, this is a better image of what conflict is supposed to look like. We aren’t pulling in the same direction. We each hold our own rope. That role is different than every other role on the team, and we have to pull in our own direction. And if we pull too hard, we yank the whole tarp off target, and the people in the tent, the customers or the shareholders, get wet, and sometimes somebody gets hurt. And if we don’t like conflict, or we don’t come prepared, or and we let go of our rope, then we leave something exposed. And so this became the story and the basis for an exercise that we do now with teams all over everywhere. And it’s actually the exercise is published in Harvard Business Review as well. And what we do is we take every role on a team. Unfortunately, it’s more than four, so it we make our tarp round so it can have a few more ropes on it, and we define three questions, and so I encourage your listeners to ask these three questions and do this exercise with their team. So, first question: What is the unique value of this role on the team? What’s their expertise? What’s their knowledge? What are their superpowers that they bring that no one else on the team brings? That’s the first question. Second question: What unique stakeholder do they have, and who are they thinking of and advocating for, and who’s putting pressure on them, and finally, what obligation do they have to question and put tension on the discussions and decisions of the team? And you’ll find when you ask these three questions about each role on the team, you create epiphanies for sure. the The comments around the table are hilarious. We tend to get a lot of like, “Oh, I just thought you were a jerk. People realize that, “Oh, that’s your job. But amazing epiphany comes, and you know, I will never forget doing this with the executive team of a big food company and talking to the head of sales. and And I said, “Okay, you know what? What’s your unique value? Well, I’m here to really customize our products to fit with each different grocery store and what they’re trying to do and fit with their brand and their packaging and their vibe. Oh, cool. Okay, and so you’re thinking about the grocery chains as your main stakeholder, yeah. And your your attention is really about is it really compelling? Is it customized? Is it differentiated? That makes sense. Then I looked at the head of operations, and he was already smiling because he was a smart man who knew what was coming. I said, “Tell me, answer the three questions for you. And he said, “Well, my unique value is to create consistency and to make things efficient, and my.” Stakeholders are more internal, and and the tension I have to put on things is: is it as efficient as possible? Is it you know are we making sure there’s as much uptime and and is it optimized? And so they started laughing because they could immediately see that those two roles are supposed to be intention. If it’s going well, they’re intention with one another. It was just so powerful, and so later when they got this massive opportunity to do all the racks of ribs for the July long weekend, and the sales guy was super excited because look at this giant order, and the ops guy was terrified because well, first of all, pigs don’t come as just ribs, and he was going to have all that scrap and waste and stuff. He was going to sell off really cheap. Plus, it’s the boning line, the most expensive line that they have to run to do that. But we now had the framework to talk about the fact that we have to make the right answer and the right call for everybody in the tent, not just the sales guy yanking so hard on it. So this exercise, and in the good fight, all of the instructions to run this with your team are fully in the book, so that you can do it without needing me. But it’s amazing how once you do this, there’s shared language around productive conflict. It becomes like flossing, as I was saying, so when you’re making a decision, you can literally just say, “Okay, we haven’t heard from this rope yet. What’s your value? What’s your tension? What’s your nobody’s talked about this stakeholder yet? What right? And it’s not, oh, I have to say something horrible. I have to get into a fight. It’s oh no, me. I’m next. I have to pull my rope, and it becomes you have both ends of the spectrum you can coach to. So the people like you and me who might have been letting down our rope and leaving something exposed, you can coach. Hey, haven’t heard yet, and you know really let’s make sure we know how this is going to impact your stakeholders. But for the people who pull too hard on the rope, who are constantly talking? You’re able to say, “Okay, we’ve heard from that perspective, but we haven’t yet heard from the others, so hang on. Or you’ve got the language to say, “You pulling that rope harder is not going to make us a better decision. It’s going to leave a lot of people in the tent wet. So the great thing about doing this exercise with your team is you get this shared language, the team leader gets the chance to coach for both ends of the spectrum, and you really get this habit of how do we optimize decisions for all of the wisdom we have in the room, all of the stakeholders that we need to represent with this decision, and with all of the tensions to make sure that we’ve made the best decision possible. So that exercise is one I’m so very proud of. And every time we do it with a team, I can meet people five years later, and they’re like, “Leanne, we’re still tarping. They’ve made it a verb. That’s always a sign that your your work has been successful. As somebody’s turned it into a, they’ve verbed it,

    Maureen: [00:22:57] kind of like xeroxing and googling. Now you’re

    Liane: [00:22:59] exactly

    Maureen: [00:23:00] you’re in that category. They’re tarping. They’re

    Liane: [00:23:02] tarping. Yes. Well, and I

    Maureen: [00:23:05] love I love that you point out the difference between the rowing and the pulling. Yeah. Because it really is all of our. I think of the old Covey posters and that stuff. They always show like the rowers as the sun’s coming up or going down, and

    Liane: [00:23:22] and I always laugh because the water is so flat. I’m like, when was the last time your business was in flat water? It’s been a while. Yeah, they could

    Maureen: [00:23:32] show people doing rapid kayak going through rapids. Yeah, yeah, that would be a much more accurate. And I think of a time I went kayaking and I fell out of the boat. I’m not a perfect. I’ve done that

    Liane: [00:23:46] too. I’ve done that too. Yeah. And then I

    Maureen: [00:23:48] got my legs stuck under a rock, and it’s yeah, it was a bad trip. And the point is, these things are hard, and they require skill.

    Liane: [00:24:00] Yeah,

    Maureen: [00:24:00] and it just takes time to learn how to to navigate that to continue with the rough water analogy that how we behaved even months ago now a year ago pre pandemic and what a lifetime ago well and how many people we’ve been for those lucky enough to be able to work from home, we’ve been working from home and had less, in some cases, less conflict because we, if we like the people we live with, we’ve had less conflict. Yeah, that’s an interesting

    Liane: [00:24:33] point because what we’ve seen is a lot of conflict dead on teams. So another one of our socializations is that if you have to have a difficult conversation, you have to have it in person, and so I’ve literally talked to people who said to me, “Well, you know, they’re telling me about a grievance they have with a coworker, and I say, ‘Okay, have you spoken? Oh no, I don’t want to do it over Zoom, so I’ll I’ll do it when we’re back in the office. I’m like, ‘You’re gonna sit on this for a year, making sure the resentment is nice and toxic, but.'” Before you bring it up, like, and so it’s another problem. We we’ve had less conflict, true, in terms of it being an an actual conversation, but we haven’t had any less conflicts, if you know what I mean, right? So our conflict debt on many teams is really getting out of control, so I worry about all the built-up hostility and resentment when we go back into the office. These people who you know we don’t think of quite the same way as we did when we left

    Maureen: [00:25:32] when we liked them,

    Liane: [00:25:33] yeah, or when we hadn’t had a self-inflicted wound. Like the the quote I think about all the time is Nelson Mandela, who they asked him, you know, did you resent your jailers who who beat you, and and he said no because I understand that resentment is like swallowing poison, hoping the other person will die, and so I think there have been a lot of people swallowing poison this year, resenting their teammates, feeling unacknowledged for how much they’re doing that no one can see because they’re doing it at home, and all of that resentment is going to come back with us to an office where I think for some teams it’s going to be really challenging.

    Maureen: [00:26:10] That’s an interesting point, and it seems that we need to build the skills to work remotely, not just how to use Zoom, which we’ve all mastered. Sort of.

    Liane: [00:26:22] I still muck it up sometimes.

    Maureen: [00:26:24] We have gotten to a level that is acceptable. We all still leave the mute on sometimes, and that’s yeah. But my sense is we will also develop the capacity to create resonance across the miles you and I are in different countries, yeah, and we can create a strong resonance on a screen. And because you and I both now have habits of dealing with complexity and challenge, my guess is if we had a conflict, we would process it,

    Liane: [00:27:00] figure it out. Yeah, I did a YouTube video on how to have conflict remotely, and I actually point out in that video about how, in some ways, it has huge advantages. Like, for one, you can take notes for yourself and put them beside the camera on the screen to just remind you of even a little sticker of a happy face to remember to you know try and keep smiling because I always tell people this like even if you’re on the phone and you think it doesn’t matter it does because the way that your mouth is shaped if you’re just listen to my voice with your eyes closed if if you listen to my voice when I’m not smiling and then you listen to my voice when I’m smiling the pitch is higher because when you pull up your muscles to smile, you actually lift your soft palate, which changes the shape of the resonance chamber of your voice, and the person on the other end can pick it up whether it’s subconscious or not. So you know when you’re having a conflict in the office, putting a smiley face on your palm, you look like a bit of a dork if you have like cheating on the exam notes. But if you’re on on Zoom, it’s really easy to have that little sticker reminding you that if you’re having the conversation while smiling, they’ll pick it up subconsciously. So there’s some big advantages that if we just got over our mindset, which is I’m not supposed to have hard conversations virtually, and just realize that yeah, I’m supposed to have hard conversations when they come up, so I don’t get into conflict. That that much better to pay off the $7 than to wait till it’s 100 bucks with interest and penalties. And I agree with you. I think we’re going to learn all these skills. And and remember, there are some big advantages. And even just so you talked about conflict being unsafe. Well, just think about even for your brain, the little bit more safety when it’s separated through a screen. No one’s going to physically lay their hands on you. You’re safe from that. So there are some advantages to, and those big, huge men don’t look so big and scary in a little in a little square. You can even shrink the square if you want. Make them smaller. You can’t do that in person. So there’s some big advantages. And once we get over that hurdle of our own, you know, norms of having conflict in person, we’ll realize that we can do this. And in some ways, it’s better.

    Maureen: [00:29:13] As an introvert, I am happy to be at a distance from people who are frustrated with me.

    Liane: [00:29:18] Yeah,

    Maureen: [00:29:18] I had a niece live with me for a while, and when we were in conflict, she would text me. I remember talking to one of my colleagues who was like, “That’s terrible. I’m like, “Oh no, it’s bad. Works for

    Liane: [00:29:30] me, yeah.

    Maureen: [00:29:30] Because I got to understand the challenge and got to formulate a response before I had pubescent young person

    Liane: [00:29:41] right yelling

    Maureen: [00:29:41] at me. This was for an introvert, and I can’t talk about you know that whole percentage of the population having the space to formulate a well thought out response. To your point, I can draw a smile. I can think about all the reasons I love having her live with me. So I’m not responding with. Whatever the dishes in the sink thing, right? Thinking about, I adore this person, and there are dishes in the sink. In perspective, the conflicts are back to its flossing.Liane: [00:30:14] Exactly, right? It’s a $7 thing. Why pay $100 for it when everybody gets in a huff and right? So I completely, completely agree with that. And people underestimate the importance of giving a heads up to a difficult conversation you want to have. Because if you’re the person who’s been sitting with resentment or grievance or issue, you’ve had time to prepare and to have all your great examples and to tell a whole story and all those kinds of things, and if you ambush them, and they’re naturally then defending and protecting, which is just normal, you’re much more likely to go down the root canal path. Whereas if you give them a bit of a heads up, you know, I felt like this morning’s meeting when you said this, I didn’t know how to take it. I’m telling myself a bad story at the moment. Would love to touch base with you and get a sense, and then the person can be like, “I don’t even remember saying that. They could touch base with someone and say, “Did I say that? The other person can be like, “Yeah, actually, you did say that. You’re like, “Oh, right. Like then it’s much more of a level playing field and much less likely to be in that emotional fight, flight, or freeze moment. So I’m a big proponent of more of a heads up, more of a level playing field, and and use writing to signal the conversation and let the other person be better prepared. I think that’s just kinder, and of course it’s not what our norms are. We think the right thing to do is to go up and look them in the eye and say something, but to me that just-and I’m not an introvert, but that feels like an ambush to me. So that’s maybe where it comes at for me. I’m not an I’m not an introvert, but I’m very sensitive. So you’re going to hurt me, and then I’m going to protect myself.

    Maureen: [00:31:53] Well, and you scare me when you say things like “we need to talk. That is like the worst thing to say. It it signals something dire has happened or will happen. Right. So to your point, you said something in the meeting this morning that hurt my feelings. I just want to close the loop. Different than different to talk where I hear you’re an absolute incompetent or something, and

    Liane: [00:32:19] right

    Maureen: [00:32:19] bad. I gotta be

    Liane: [00:32:20] fired. Yeah,

    Maureen: [00:32:22] that’s what I think. It’s the your dad’s gonna be home and he’s got that big board he’s gonna hit you with. And instead, it’s just I wish you wouldn’t say something just to close the loop on that. And you were gonna say

    Liane: [00:32:34] yeah. So I had a boss who used to just send an email with the subject line time to chat question mark, and I finally had to tell him that I was going to physically hurt him if he did it again because it just provoked this horrible fear in me and everyone else. So don’t do the time to chat, but just say in the meeting, I don’t feel like we resolve this. You know, I’d like a chance to come back to it, or this hurt my feelings, or I’m telling myself a story that might not be true and would love to hear from you firsthand. So yeah, don’t do it in a way that because if you just say time to chat, you’re not leveling the playing field. You’re not giving them any chance to prepare. You’re just double ambushing them with the email and with the chat. So you want to give them enough that they actually can collect their thoughts, can maybe collect some information, and be ready to have the conversation as equal partners in the conversation instead of getting talked at

    Maureen: [00:33:25] more of the tarp.

    Liane: [00:33:26] Absolutely,

    Maureen: [00:33:27] Leanne. Now let’s talk about community organizations and how they fare differently than in some cases

    Liane: [00:33:36] corporates. It’s not a pretty picture, Maureen. It’s just, it’s so interesting because many years ago I was sitting on the board of a not-for-profit, a very important subject near and dear to my heart, and I was sitting in a board meeting thinking, this is even worse than the conflict at my day job, and I get paid to go to my day job, so I started investigating what what is that about? Why do we not have productive conflict in our not for profit, in our volunteer organizations, in our synagogues and churches and mosques and all these places that so many of us, the PTA, goodness gracious, that’s another good one. And I I really saw three different stories that people tell themselves as to why they don’t engage in productive conflict, why they drop the rope in the tarp metaphor. So the first is that they just tell themselves that, well, you know, this is such an important cause. Like this is about people with cancer, and so who am I to complain about how I’m being treated, or this or that? Right? You you are so focused on this very very important cause that you subjugate your own needs to the cause. So that’s one thing. The second thing is a lot of the dysfunctional behavior is coming from other people who are volunteering their time. So you think, well. He’s volunteering his time. Beggars can’t be choosers. I’ll cut him some slack, and we put up with dysfunctional behavior. And then the third one is that the the leadership in the not for profit sector isn’t always great, and so sometimes we’re kind of making excuses for weak leaders in the organization, even if they’re paid staff. So we have all these great reasons that we tell ourselves for why we put up with it, but I actually take those exact three reasons and say that’s exactly why you need to do the hard things, have the hard conversations. Because a, this issue is so important that it really needs you to get the issues on the table. Secondly, because it is your volunteer time. This is supposed to be something that enriches your life and helps you decompress from your day job. So it’s another reason why you deserve for it to be a healthy dynamic. And finally, because the leadership maybe isn’t so strong, and they need your help in broaching these tough issues and and taking difficult stakeholders and getting them to the other side. So, really, you can add so much value as a member of a charity, a not-for-profit, a community organization if you’re the one who can help. Well, even helping with the TARP example. So, I was going through a TARP example with a very large not-for-profit, and it was an issue between the head of fundraising and the head of programs, and the head of programs was a very kind, generous, empathetic, sensitive soul because that’s what you want as somebody building your social service programs. He was a lovely human, and he was sensitive, and things, you know, he had a thin skin. Things upset him, and the head of fundraising Was a strong, dominant doesn’t take no for an answer, and they were clashing with one another, and and I just did the tarp exercise, and I just started saying, okay, what’s the head of fundraising? What are her superpowers? Well, one of her superpowers is how strong and assertive and convincing, and what a steamroller she is, because you wouldn’t have any money to run your programs if she took no for an answer. So let’s remember that that’s what we need from her. And then to her, who had kind of been looking down her nose at him as a bit of a wimp, said, “What’s his superpower? He feels everything very profoundly, and that’s what makes him good at building programs. That’s the point, and you wouldn’t be able to raise funds because the programs would suck if you didn’t have somebody. So, you know, if you are somebody who can help your community organization through the TARP to understand the tensions that are supposed to be there, if you can help broach and stop minding your own business and instead help people get to the other side of some of these conflicts. You will be in hot demand, just as much as somebody can make great cupcakes for the bake sale or has a pickup truck. These are people in great demand in the world. Somebody who can make a great lemon square. Somebody who has a pickup truck, and somebody who can help the community work through some of those contentious issues. So, yeah, that’s been a big theme for me, and in in the good fight, the first nine chapters are all about in the workplace and and productive conflict there. But I I riffed off of the funny line in commercials when they’re doing crazy things with stunt drivers, and it says don’t try this at home. And I have a bonus chapter called Try This at Home, and it talks about conflict in a healthy marriage, raising conflict, constructive conflict, children, and then contributing in our communities with productive conflict. So that was a fun chapter to write to get into some of these other places where we need conflict just as much as we do in our organizations.

    Maureen: [00:38:34] If home is a safe place, it’s a wonderful place to practice.

    Liane: [00:38:38] Yes,

    Maureen: [00:38:39] because again, I will make the assumption that if it’s a safe place, we’re more forgiving. These are the people we actually chose to be with. Some of our coworkers we wouldn’t have chosen. In my relationship now, it’s one of the things I like most is that we have those conversations like flossing, and

    Liane: [00:38:58] it is

    Maureen: [00:38:59] often. I mean, there’s stuff when you live with a person and you manage a budget. And

    Liane: [00:39:04] yeah, one person likes the vacation with no plans, just a plane ticket and nothing else, and the other one likes the vacation where every hour is planned and the tickets are bought a year in advance. And you know, that’s that’s okay. That’s the spice of life. But if you let it blow up, right, then it’s going to be a problem. So yeah, how do you get to the flossing model? And in a way, and it’s very hard when there are situations that are not as safe. It’s very very challenging. But in theory, you want to avoid the explosive moments as much as possible. And so the more you can learn ways of, you know, getting the issues out when they’re very small, and and people who have to manage unsafe or unhealthy situations become very savvy at that, right? How to navigate and and manage these things to avoid explosiveness. And my book is not not about those unsafe situations. I have no expertise in that, but in a good relationship. Yeah, the flossing approach is a is a really good one.

    Maureen: [00:40:03] Well, and I would add the value of humor. I’m thinking about my relationship and the the comments. I said something this morning about the list of things to do this weekend, and he was like, “Oh, I love when you plan our weekends with house tasks, and it was right. Just a gentle like, really, you’ve planned every minute of the weekend already with house projects, and it was the nice way to say, like, are we going to do something fun too?

    Liane: [00:40:28] Fun, yeah.

    Maureen: [00:40:29] And that was all that was required. Now I have backed off on my noted some expectations. Yeah, it’s going to happen over the month, not the day.

    Liane: [00:40:38] Yeah, and it leads to a really great follow-up question. Just is like, what would feel like the right amount of our weekend to devote to to those kinds of tasks, and and you know, what kinds of things do we want done by when, right? And and you know, there’s all sorts of great questions because it might be that his version ends up with the you know the patio furniture being all good to go in October, which is less of a good plan. So, so there’s give and take when you have some good open questions, so that you can actually communicate with one another about these things. So, but I love the the subtle little like hint of like him.

    Maureen: [00:41:17] Well, and humor just works so much better for us. Yeah, it’s. I got the point. Roger that. That’s pretty much all Isaiah’s got it.

    Liane: [00:41:27] Yeah,

    Maureen: [00:41:28] we know each other well enough to to know what the agreement is about how we spend our weekends.

    Liane: [00:41:33] Yes, we

    Maureen: [00:41:34] we all have our things. So, what do you want to make sure our listeners take away? We’ve heard manage the debt, create the process, create the common language, and do it. Deal with the childhood stuff.

    Liane: [00:41:49] Yeah. So I would say that the line that I tell people to remember is: some things are worth fighting for.

    Maureen: [00:41:58] I love that, and this is your superpower, and people can learn

    Liane: [00:42:02] it absolutely. And and the skills are not hard. The skills I can teach you, they’re very easy. I have a whole YouTube channel of the skills. That’s not the issue. It’s the doing the work to understand what’s your baggage and who’s in your itty bitty committee and who’s telling you what are they telling you and to really do the work to realize it’s like your own therapy. Doing the work to realize that I choose not to listen to those voices anymore. They’re not right, and I’m getting into more trouble getting in conflict debt than I would have been if I just paid it off initially when the issue was still small and we could have it with humor and we could address it and move on.

    Maureen: [00:42:42] So, Leanne, we’ve got about a minute left. Where do people reach you? Your YouTube channel, your book, your

    Liane: [00:42:47] yeah

    Maureen: [00:42:48] LinkedIn. How would you like people to connect? Yeah.

    Liane: [00:42:50] So the YouTube channel is just Leanne Davy, which the only hard part there is the spelling, but it’ll be in the title of the episode, I’m sure. But L I A N E D A V E Y, and that’s also my website, LeanneDayvi.com, and those are the two best places. And then I’m really active on LinkedIn. And so if you have questions, if you want to engage with me, I post every single week, twice, free tools and resources to help bring the good fight into your life.

    Maureen: [00:43:17] And in companion with this interview, we’re going to do a blog and ask you to share one of those tools, so that listeners can have something concrete to walk through. And as we close, I want to thank you for joining us. Thank our listeners for joining us, and encourage our listeners look her up on YouTube and LinkedIn, and leave us comments. We want to hear how you are getting better based on the conversations we’re sharing with you. So thank you, and think about making conflict your superpower, navigating conflict as your superpower, not instinct.