Innovating Leadership:
Co-Creating Our Future
Hosted by Maureen Metcalf
Conversations with global thought leaders on leadership, culture, and innovation—designed for executives navigating complexity and building resilient organizations.
Leading in Circles: The Inevitable Circular Economy
Episode Description
Christoph Hinske delivers a pointed challenge: the circular economy will fail to deliver on its promise if leadership mindsets and behaviors stay the same. He observes that roughly 80 percent of organizations attempting systemic transformation simply keep doing the old things with fancy new words, applying linear thinking to a fundamentally circular problem. Drawing on the Innovative Leadership Mindset and Competency model, he argues that genuine change demands leaders who evolve their thinking, presence, and actions and who grasp the complex, systems level relationships that drive real transformation.
Key Takeaways
- The circular economy cannot deliver on its promise unless leadership mindsets and behaviors genuinely change.
- Technology and governance structures alone are insufficient without accompanying leadership evolution.
- About 80 percent of transformation efforts repackage old practices in new language rather than truly reimagining operations.
- Circular economy leaders must evolve their thinking, presence, and actions, not just their vocabulary.
- Systems level understanding of cause and effect among actors and structures is essential to success.
Why This Episode Matters
Executives come away understanding that any systemic transformation, from sustainability to the circular economy, depends first on evolving how leaders themselves think and act.
Featuring
Episode Topics
Podcast Air Date
Episode Duration
Watch the episode
Episode Content:
Leading in Circles: The Inevitable Circular Economy
Christoph Hinske, associate professor at the School of Finance and Accounting at SAXION University of Applied Sciences, covering Systems Leadership and Entrepreneurial Ecosystems, and Maureen Metcalf, CEO of the Innovative Leadership Institute, provide this article as a companion to their podcast Leading in Circles: The Inevitable Circular Economy. It summarizes the recently published book that Christoph edited, The Impossibilities of the Circular Economy: Separating Aspirations from Reality.
Introduction to Chapter 10: Circular Economy Leadership In Organizations by Christoph Hinske and Maureen Metcalf
There is no doubt that new technologies, governance structures, values, and interaction dynamics are fundamental to implementing the Circular Economy. However, it is leaders who build and run the organization on this foundation. The chapter discusses how applying well-tested leadership frameworks provide a crucial piece of the puzzle required to turn the Circular Economy from an impossibility to a probability.
Using the Innovative Leadership Mindset and Competency model, this chapter discusses the leadership needed for the Circular Economy. The authors argue that the leadership required to succeed in a Circular Economy is fundamentally different from traditional leadership. To succeed in the Circular Economy, leaders must evolve how they think, their presence as leaders, and what they do to progress circular economies successfully. In addition, they must understand the complexity of the underlying cause and effect behind interactions between actors, events, and structures and whether these influence their actions and strategies.
Furthermore, the chapter claims that the Circular Economy will not deliver against its promises if leadership mindsets and behaviours remain unchanged. While the Circular Economy advocates are overpromising its impact, working on leadership mindsets and associated behaviours is essential to move this critical agenda forward and improve its environmental, economic, and social effects.
Christoph commissioned a comic to walk readers through crucial elements as part of the book. The images below represent a subset we thought you would appreciate. The open-source version of the book and the comic are available for download at no cost.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Mr. Christoph Hinske is an associate professor at the School of Finance and Accounting at SAXION University of Applied Sciences, covering Systems Leadership and Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. In his work, Christoph observed that our rapidly transforming economies force leaders to be systemic since they need to act in complex, ambiguous ecosystems. Consequently, his research focuses on empowering leaders to change their strategic and operational models from linear to circular to ecosystemic. He observed that 80 of organizations, intending to transform their models to be more systemic, continue doing the old stuff, using new fancy words. They still apply the same tools, mindsets, and frameworks developed to build linear success.
Maureen Metcalf is the founder and CEO of the Innovative Leadership Institute. She is an expert in anticipating and leveraging future business trends. Ms. Metcalf helps leaders elevate their leadership quality and transform their organizations to create sustainable impact and results. She captures 30 years of experience and success in an award-winning series of books used by public, private, and academic organizations to align company-wide strategy, systems, and culture using Innovative Leadership techniques. Ms. Metcalf is a Fellow of the International Leadership Association. She also serves on the advisory boards of the School of Strategic Leadership at James Madison University and the Mason Leadership Center at Franklin University. Ms. Metcalf earned an MBA from Virginia Tech. She can be reached at mmetcalf@innovativeleadership.com.
Resources:
Here are the links to Christoph’s book, The Impossibilities of the Circular Economy: Separating Expectations from Reality:
Regular Narrative Edition = https://www.routledge.com/The-Impossibilities-of-the-Circular-Economy-Separating-aspirations-from/Lehmann-Hinske-Margerie-Nikolova/p/book/9781032154435
Graphic Novel Style Edition = https://360dialogues.com/360portfolios/ce-impossibilities
Other episodes you’ll enjoy
- Inside Amazon’s Big Bets: Leading on Climate and Delivery with Kara Hurst and Sarah Mathew
- Coming Soon to a Business Climate Near You! with Matthew Griffin
- Leading Smart Cities: Transforming Work & Life with Nikki Greenberg and Ugo Valenti
Guest(s):
Guest(s) Bio:
Mr. Christoph Hinske is an associate professor at the School of Finance and Accounting at SAXION University of Applied Sciences, covering Systems Leadership and Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. In his work, Christoph observed that our rapidly transforming economies force leaders to be systemic since they need to act in complex, ambiguous ecosystems. Consequently, his research focuses on empowering leaders to change their strategic and operational models from linear to circular to ecosystemic. He observed that 80 of organizations, intending to transform their models to be more systemic, continue doing the old stuff, using new fancy words. They still apply the same tools, mindsets, and frameworks developed to build linear success.
Want to be a guest on the Innovating Leadership Podcast?
Want to sponsor the Innovating Leadership Podcast?

Our Podcast Team:

Maureen Metcalf
Podcast Host

Dan Mushalko
Editor & Producer

Jenna Reik
Podcast Manager
Transcript
(auto-generated)
Transcript







